Selina Commodore Astoria
Praised forgreat location · friendly staff · unique historic charm
Flagged fornoisy rooms · lack of air conditioning · cleanliness concerns
Love the old architecture built into modern amenities
Right in the heart of downtown Astoria. You can walk just about all of the main downtown from the hotel.
It's a cute hotel. Was met by the owner on our arrival. Cute coffee shop attached with a great breakfast.
Cons As many reviews state - it's loud. It's an older hotel and they have been working on sound proofing, but the street outside isn't something I can do much about. The bad for me was leaving my credit card at the restaurant. This is 100% my fault, but I called after driving an hour away. No one at the hotel or restaurant called me back. I called and wrote an email and 2 days later heard something. As I know the owner was there this seemed like dropping the ball on the customer service end.
We didn't even stay, we went and booked a different hotel that same night because of how disappointed we were.
It was in a convenient location and close to several shops and restaurants.
Cons It doesn't make it clear that there isn't a bathroom attached to the room, only a sink in the room. You have to go to the first floor in order to use the bathroom or shower. The room was small. Parking was hard to find. Not suited for people checking in after 9 pm, as you get fined a late check in fee.
Great location. Good size room.
Great location. good room
Amazing hotel and staff, we weary of the parking situation...
The rooms were great, and it was nice to have the passcode to our room be associated with our phone number when checking in, making the entire process pretty easy and seamless to get into our room and finally sit down after such a long drive.
Cons My only complaint about this hotel is the atrocious parking situation. Once we got to Astoria, we probably circled the block the hotel was on for half an hour, through busy one-way streets packed with pedestrians that made it super stressful to find anywhere to park! We ended up parking about a 5-8 min walk away from the hotel, which was the closest we could find after about half an hour, and then had to drag our luggage (2 Rucks and two backpacks) to the hotel.
