Boise, ID

Hotel Renegade delivers beautiful rooms and great service most of the time, but room quality varies wildly. Request a downtown-facing room because alley rooms get hammered by garbage trucks at 4am. Business travelers complain about poor storage and undersized furniture, though the rooftop bar and on-site restaurants impress.

Rooms are clean and comfortable with nice touches like fireplaces and good views, but the AC system is old and struggles to cool properly when the fireplace runs. Staff go out of their way to make special occasions memorable through upgrades and personalized service. The on-site restaurant is solid and the location near downtown and the Greenbelt is convenient.

Rooms are spacious, clean, and quiet with comfortable beds and good insulation. Staff genuinely remembers guests by name and goes out of their way to help. The included breakfast and evening social hour with drinks are solid perks, though plant-based options are limited.

Spacious, clean rooms and helpful staff make this a solid choice. The heated pool and downtown location work well. Skip the in-room coffee and bring your own towels - the hotel runs short on them, especially pool towels on busy days.

The Grove delivers clean, spacious rooms with plush bedding and thoughtful touches like wine and cheese plates. Staff go out of their way to make guests feel welcomed. The downtown location puts you steps from restaurants, shops, and the river.

The bed is comfortable but the room is tight with poor layout. Parking charges add up, the elevator breaks often, and noise from construction and nearby Boise State keeps some guests awake. Staff is friendly and the location is good downtown.

Hotel 43 offers a great downtown location with friendly staff and clean spaces, but the rooms feel dated with uncomfortable beds and weak shower pressure. One guest reported missing valuables from their room, and management refused a cancellation request, so consider the risks before booking.

Beds are hard and uncomfortable. Rooms often dirty with stains and debris left behind. Staff quality varies wildly, from exceptional to unhelpful. Parking is difficult. No complimentary breakfast. Good downtown location near attractions.