Boise, ID

Hotel Renegade delivers beautiful rooms and great service most of the time, but room quality varies wildly. Request a downtown-facing room because alley rooms get hammered by garbage trucks at 4am. Business travelers complain about poor storage and undersized furniture, though the rooftop bar and on-site restaurants impress.

Rooms are spacious and generally clean with good sound insulation, though one guest reported musty smell and an uncomfortable bed with a sinking headrest. Staff responds quickly to problems and the hotel doesn't charge holding fees. Most guests loved their stays, but room quality seems inconsistent.

Rooms are clean and comfortable with nice touches like fireplaces and good views, but the AC system is old and struggles to cool properly when the fireplace runs. Staff go out of their way to make special occasions memorable through upgrades and personalized service. The on-site restaurant is solid and the location near downtown and the Greenbelt is convenient.

Rooms are spacious, clean, and quiet with comfy beds and good insulation despite airport and highway noise. Staff know guests by name and go above and beyond. Breakfast and evening social hour with drinks are included, though vegan options are limited.

Rooms are clean and comfortable with good beds. Suites work well for families and groups. Staff goes above and beyond, though breakfast is just okay.

Rooms are clean and comfortable with quality beds. Staff is genuinely friendly and breakfast is solid. Downtown location puts restaurants and bars within walking distance, but parking garage is pricey and annoying to use, and early morning garbage noise disturbs some guests.

Rooms are spacious and clean with comfortable beds. Staff are consistently kind and helpful. The heated pool and gym are solid perks, but the in-room coffee is terrible and housekeeping sometimes runs short on pool towels during busy periods.

Beds and sheets are genuinely excellent. Staff quality varies wildly depending on who works that day, from exceptional service to rudeness about room changes. The hotel is clean, allows pets, serves decent breakfast, and sits near the airport with a shuttle.

The Sparrow has a comfortable bed and friendly staff, but the tiny rooms lack closets and bedside tables, the elevator frequently breaks down, parking is poorly managed despite extra charges, and noise from nearby construction and rowdy guests disrupts sleep. You pay premium prices for motel-level amenities with expensive add-ons.

Rooms are spacious, spotless, and feature plush bedding. Staff genuinely welcome guests and go out of their way to make stays special. The downtown location puts you steps from restaurants, shops, and the river.

Rooms are clean and quiet with good breakfast, but management uses heavy floral cleaning scents that trigger respiratory issues for some guests. Staff are genuinely helpful and friendly. Location near the river and parks works well if you're not near the airport.

Hotel 43 has a great downtown location and friendly staff, but rooms feel dated with an uncomfortable bed, small shower, and weak water pressure. One guest reported missing valuables after checkout, and management refused a cancellation request.

Rooms are clean and comfortable with good beds, AC, and heat. Staff goes out of their way to help guests. The free breakfast is substantial and coffee runs 24/7. Housekeeping skips rooms on multi-day stays unless you request it the night before.

Beds are hard and uncomfortable. Rooms often dirty with stains and debris left behind. Staff quality varies wildly, from exceptional to unhelpful. Parking is difficult. No complimentary breakfast. Good downtown location near attractions.

Rooms are clean and comfortable with good beds, but avoid room 227 due to constant noise above the entryway. Staff is helpful and accommodating. Breakfast is marginal, and the parking lot has trees that drop berry stains on cars.

Rooms are spacious with good AC and large TVs, but cleanliness varies wildly between stays. Narrow showers and stains on furnishings appear in some reviews. Parking costs $7 daily with confusing policies, and the small lot has only one entrance. Staff like Gary and server Eleanor stand out, and the restaurant gets genuine praise.

Rooms are comfortable and well-laid out, but cleanliness is hit or miss - some guests found mold in bathrooms and dirty showers. The AC unit runs loud and cycles constantly, disrupting sleep. Breakfast quality varies wildly. Staff stays friendly throughout.

Rooms are dusty and dirty with stained sheets, broken thermostats that make sleeping hard, and peeling wallpaper. Beds are uncomfortable and showers look gross. The location near the mall is good and breakfast is sometimes decent, but housekeeping is inconsistent and maintenance issues are common.