Classic Hotel Rooms in New York

Spacious loft rooms have great views, comfortable beds, and excellent showers with soaking tubs. Location near Chelsea, the High Line, and Broadway means you can walk everywhere. Staff are mostly friendly, though check your hot water on arrival since one guest had freezing cold showers.

The Peninsula delivers excellent service and a prime Manhattan location, though one recent guest hit climate control and concierge problems that suggest inconsistent quality. Most guests praise the immaculate rooms, quiet atmosphere, and thoughtful details like spa music in bathrooms.

Rooms feel spacious and calm with excellent bathrooms, good water pressure, quality towels, and city views. Staff delivers exceptional service and attention to detail across all departments. One guest reported a staff member made a discriminatory comment about appearance.

Rooms vary wildly. Some guests praise spacious clean rooms with great views, while others report small rooms with dirty windows and old furniture. Staff consistently delivers excellent service and attention to detail, though prices run steep for what you get.

The Beekman has spotless rooms in a beautiful building with excellent location near transit, though noise from events can reach upper floors and views vary. Service quality is inconsistent: staff excel at helping with requests but slack on proactive gestures like door assistance and responding to room service. The popular bar room gets packed on weekends.

Spacious rooms with comfortable beds and thoughtful details appeal to most guests. The staff is friendly and attentive. One guest reported serious discriminatory treatment at the bar, so experiences vary significantly depending on who serves you.

The Plaza has comfortable beds, great water pressure, and beautiful terraces with fountains. Staff go above and beyond, accommodating allergies and offering special experiences. The hotel costs a lot but guests say it's worth it.

Staff go above and beyond with personalized service and genuine attention to detail. Rooms are comfortable with high-tech amenities like advanced lighting controls. Food is excellent and the hotel handles families well, including kids' menus.

Rooms are dirty with mold, stains, and poor soundproofing. Staff is rude and unhelpful with lost items. Common areas smell like hotdogs and feel run-down. You're paying luxury prices for a neglected property.

The Pierre offers comfortable beds and old-world charm, but broken AC units and loud external machinery make rooms problematic. Staff quality varies wildly: doormen and elevator operators are exceptional, but some desk staff are rude. The restaurant food disappoints.

Great location and views, but service varies wildly. Staff ranges from exceptional to dismissive. Rooms are spacious with stunning views, though beds are hard and bathrooms show wear. No in-hotel bar access and weak room service frustrated guests.

Rooms are massive, beautifully designed, and immaculate with excellent water pressure and comfortable beds. Staff consistently goes above and beyond with genuine hospitality. The restored hotel feels elegant and quiet with stunning public spaces, though rooms have limited fridge space and in-room dining takes longer than expected.

The hotel has spacious rooms with good mattresses but severe maintenance issues: broken thermostats, no heat in winter, faulty plumbing, chipped furniture, and reported bed bugs. Staff are inconsistent and hard to reach. Prices are high for a worn-out, neglected property.

Elevators are a major problem with long waits of 5-15 minutes. Rooms are small and clean but housekeeping has issues, including dirty sheets and broken thermostats. Location is excellent but food is expensive and staff occasionally fail to handle problems well.

Rooms are small and dated with worn hallway carpets, but the hotel sits in a prime Midtown location near Penn Station and Times Square. Staff quality varies wildly, though certain standouts like Mohamed and Nada deliver exceptional service that can save a bad situation. The lobby is beautiful art deco and on-site restaurants work well, but expect noise during checkout time.

The hotel sits in a great spot near Central Park and Times Square with clean rooms and comfortable beds. Heating controls malfunction badly, elevators have long waits, and management botches disputes over false smoking charges. Staff friendliness and fair pricing help offset these infrastructure problems.

Rooms vary wildly depending on floor. Higher floors 19-22 have upgrades with comfortable beds and good views, while lower floors feel dated with dirty carpets, broken TV, poor water pressure, and noise from construction and elevators. Staff ranges from helpful to dismissive. Book high floors only if location matters more than room quality.